In the 2026 fantasy baseball landscape, second base has become a near-barren wasteland for talent. Years ago—yes, I am dating myself—shortstop was the position where fantasy managers hoped to find a simple two-category contributor. Then, for a time, catcher held that dubious distinction. Now, heading into 2026, the thinnest fantasy position is unquestionably second base. In fact, it is almost impossible to find a true five-category contributor, let alone a six-category player for those in advanced formats.
Players like Jazz Chisholm headline the position, but his declining batting average and ongoing durability concerns make him far from a sure thing. Brice Turang showed some power last season, but whether that growth is sustainable remains a major question. Ketel Marte continues to thrive in real-life baseball, yet he is aging and no longer provides much speed. Beyond that, players such as Nico Hoerner, who help in three or four categories, are being ranked as top-10 options, which illustrates just how shallow the position has become.
One name that appears underrated heading into the season is familiar to New York fans: Gleyber Torres. Torres profiles as a steady option at an otherwise volatile position. He has an established track record while still being young enough to offer some remaining upside. Now playing for a strong Detroit lineup, Torres spent much of last season hitting near the top or middle of the order, which helped stabilize his fantasy value.
He is unlikely to be drafted inside the top five at the position and may not crack the top 10, but that makes him an excellent value. Torres is one of the few second basemen who can still contribute across the board. He should approach 20 home runs, steal double-digit bases, and post a batting average that will not hurt your team. His counting stats should land near 80 runs and 70 RBIs, with upside depending on lineup placement.
Torres’ fantasy profile may not scream superstar, but at such a thin position, steady and reliable production is a valuable commodity.