The San Diego Padres were eliminated in the first round of the playoffs this past week by the Chicago Cubs. After once again falling short of the division crown to the Los Angeles Dodgers, the franchise now faces a critical crossroads with its roster construction.
The decisions the Padres make this offseason will also cause a ripple through the fantasy baseball community, with several big names potentially on the move. General manager A.J. Preller’s choices will likely begin with the bullpen, a key area to watch for fantasy players.
Robert Suarez enjoyed another strong season, recording 40 saves with a 2.97 ERA and a 27.9% strikeout rate. Suarez is signed through 2027 but holds an opt-out clause after this season. Should he exercise it, he would immediately become the best closer available in free agency and could secure a larger contract than his current five-year, $46 million deal. At age 34, however, a long-term extension at a slightly reduced rate could keep him in San Diego.
If Suarez departs, Mason Miller appears ready to take over closing duties. Just 26 years old and under team control through 2029, Miller offers stability for the Padres’ late-inning plans.
Elsewhere, Luis Arraez is almost certain to be moved. The 28-year-old contact specialist is capable of hitting .300 annually, but his lack of walks, limited power, and defensive shortcomings make him a poor fit for a cash-strapped team.
Ryan O’Hearn could also be on the way out. His power numbers dipped in San Diego, and with below-average defensive metrics, he has profiled more as a designated hitter — a role the Padres can’t afford to carry.
Finally, starters Michael King and Dylan Cease are both set for free agency. Given the team’s financial constraints, San Diego will likely have to choose between the two arms.