The New York Islanders open the 2025 season with many of the same questions that have lingered over the franchise in recent years. Chief among them: can this team generate enough offense to become a legitimate playoff contender?
The Islanders’ offensive struggles were front and center again last season, culminating in a disappointing campaign that even strong goaltending and solid defensive structure couldn’t salvage. Injuries were prevalent and of course made matters worse, but those setbacks may have been a blessing in disguise. Rather than continuing to hope for sudden improvement, the Islanders were finally forced to face reality—and embrace a much-needed, and long overdue rebuild.
While “rebuild” is often a dreaded word among fans and players, Islanders supporters appear to understand its necessity. After securing the No. 1 overall pick in the 2025 NHL Draft, the future looks far more promising for those in blue and orange. Optimism, for once, is grounded in direction rather than blind hope.
A major front-office change further signals a new chapter. Legend Lou Lamoriello’s contract was not renewed, and Mathieu Darche was hired as general manager, ushering in a fresh vision from the top down. On the ice, the team made a bold move by trading defenseman Noah Dobson at the draft. In his place, top pick Matthew Schaefer is expected to step in and develop into a franchise cornerstone.
Last season’s numbers told the story: the Islanders tied for 27th in the NHL with just 2.71 goals per game and had the league’s worst power play. Defensively, they slipped as well—ranking 20th in goals against (3.13) and 31st in penalty kill percentage.
The excitement is real, and the future is bright, but results may take time. Until the Islanders fix their special teams, they remain a rebuilding team with playoff aspirations—not expectations.