School’s Out: Former Sachem Elementary PTA President Arrested for Grand Larceny


If not stealing from your own organization is cool, then call us Miles Davis | Sachem Schools/Youtube & Billy Madison (1995)

$27,000 is a remarkable amount of school lunches.

Pamela McManus, 42, of Holbrook allegedly stole well over this much from Nokomis Elementary School’s Parent Teacher Association (PTA), upon which she served as President from July 1st, 2021 to June 30th, 2024. 

According to Suffolk County District Attorney Ramond A. Tierney, who announced McManus’ arrest and subsequent arraignment this past week, an investigation determined that McManus had sole access to the PTA bank account through a Visa Debit Card. 

“Parent Teacher Associations are an integral part of our school communities throughout Suffolk  County,” DA Tierney said. “The allegations in this case represent a disturbing  betrayal of trust, and my office will continue to hold accountable those who unlawfully abuse their  positions for personal gain.” 

The disgraced former Sachem School District Elementary PTA head’s bank account access even transcended her presidential tenure. When she turned over the account to the remaining PTA board members last October, numerous personal expenses were instantly detected. 

Purchases were made from Amazon, Walmart, Target, Verizon Wireless, PSEG, Sephora and Dick’s Sporting Goods. Such paints a modern-day, smaller-scale but nevertheless morally askance portrait of a Long Island school district representative gone rogue with greed, a la the Roslyn School District scandal of the early 2000s. 

Per reports, McManus is also alleged to have stolen cash directly from the PTA bank account through equally unauthorized withdrawals. These transactions are considered unlawful for occurring out of session, during summer and holiday breaks. 

McManus surrendered to the DA’s office on June 5th. Her official charge is one count of Grand Larceny in the Third Degree (Class D Felony). 

This offense is considered non-bail eligible under New York State law. She was released on her own recognizance, and is due back in court on July 10th. 

Organizations Included in this History


Daily Feed

Sports

Record Setting Maggie McCormick Competes at Nationals

The Bay Shore Schools Board of Education recently recognized and congratulated girls varsity cross country standout Maggie McCormick for her outstanding achievements on the track and on the national stage. McCormick, who has committed to the University of Florida, was honored for her performance at the Nike Cross Country Nationals, one of the most prestigious high school running events in the country.


Sports

Ducks Have First Signing of 2026

The Long Island Ducks have announced the team’s first signing of 2026, welcoming Major League veteran outfielder Jacob Robson. Robson will begin his first season with the Ducks, his second in the Atlantic League, and his 10th season in professional baseball.


Local

The King is Back in the South Shore Press

The legendary Long Island journalist Karl Grossman’s latest column.