In a dramatic legal filing, two New York residents have taken on the city and state authorities over mandatory vaccination policies. On January 14, 2026, Tashima Elaine Thomas and Jelahn Julian Griffith filed a complaint in the District Court of the United States for the Eastern District of New York against Michelle Morse, Commissioner of the NYC Education Department, among others. The plaintiffs argue that mandatory vaccinations infringe upon their constitutional rights and cultural beliefs.
The case brought by Thomas and Griffith raises significant constitutional questions regarding mandatory vaccinations. They claim that these mandates violate the First Amendment's "free exercise clause" by imposing a substantial burden on their religious liberties. The plaintiffs assert that forcing vaccines disregards their cultural and religious traditions, stating, "No department or agency should disrespect religious rights of any belief." The complaint further argues that denying education due to non-compliance with vaccination requirements effectively denies individuals their right to education itself.
Thomas and Griffith seek a court-issued Writ of Quia Timet (injunction) to restrain the defendants from enforcing statutes they believe are contrary to treaties, constitutional laws, and state charters. They emphasize the need for alternative options such as opt-outs for vaccines to avoid coercion and potential medical issues arising from forced compliance. The plaintiffs argue that not providing religious exemptions creates an environment of discrimination and burdens departments' policies with unconstitutional provisions.
The plaintiffs are seeking several forms of relief from the court. They request an immediate cease to what they describe as violations of constitutional articles at both state and federal levels. They also seek recognition of religious exemptions as valid opt-out choices for vaccinations, arguing that this would align with historical treaties and constitutional protections. Additionally, they call for a stay order while awaiting a response or decision on their petition.
Representing themselves in this case are Tashima Elaine Thomas and Jelahn Julian Griffith, who have filed in propria persona sui juris. The case is presided over by Chief Judge Margo K. Brodie in the Eastern District Court of New York under Case ID 1:26-cv-00265.
Source: 126cv00265_Thomas_v_Morse_Complaint_Eastern_District_New_York.pdf