On Tuesday, April 22, voters in the Mastics-Moriches-Shirley Community Library district will be asked to weigh in on the proposed 2025 library budget and elect two trustees to serve on the board.
We urge our readers to vote yes on the budget and to cast their votes for Joe Maiorana and Nancy Kimmerling, two proven leaders with a deep commitment to public service, fiscal stewardship, and community growth.
In a time of inflation and rising costs across nearly every sector, it would be understandable for some to approach any tax levy increase with caution. But the facts in this case speak clearly.
The proposed budget calls for a modest $35 annual increase for the average homeowner — just $2.90 a month — in exchange for access to a newly renovated state-of-the-art main library in Shirley and two beautifully reimagined branches in Mastic Beach and Moriches.
This is not just a wise investment — it is a remarkable value.
While libraries in general have seen their roles evolve in the digital age, the Mastics-Moriches-Shirley Community Library stands as a model of relevance and impact. It is among the most-used libraries in Suffolk County, and for good reason.
The library offers far more than books and reference materials. It delivers vital services that residents depend on — from English as a Second Language (ESL) instruction and high school equivalency classes to arts workshops, computer training, job search resources, and streaming services like Kanopy that allow patrons to watch thousands of films and documentaries at no cost.
This is not an outdated institution made obsolete by the internet. It is a thriving community hub — a place where families gather, seniors stay connected, and people of all ages learn, grow, and find support. The idea that we no longer need libraries because “we now have Google” is not only shortsighted, it is out of step with the reality of what libraries like MMSCL offer every day.
We also recognize that local taxpayers have legitimate concerns about rising property taxes. But the library’s portion of a typical homeowner’s bill amounts to approximately eight percent — a small slice that delivers an outsized return.
Some may be tempted to “send a message” by voting down this modest proposal. We urge our readers not to let frustration with broader tax burdens fall on one of the most transparent, effective, and beneficial public services in the community.
In our view, the MMSCL is one of the best investments this community can make — and one of the few public institutions that touches lives so directly, so frequently, and so affordably.
In this context, the library board’s oversight matters more than ever. Over the past five years, every member of the board has demonstrated strong fiscal stewardship — guiding the building project to completion while consistently delivering responsible, sustainable operating budgets.
This year, three candidates are vying for two open seats. We believe no case has been made for changing the board’s leadership. Under the steady hand of Board President Joe Maiorana, the library completed a multi-year, multi-location construction and renovation project — all while navigating the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic, supply chain disruptions, and cost volatility. Joe’s experience, consistency, and results-driven leadership have been instrumental in bringing the board’s long-term vision to life.
Likewise, Nancy Kimmerling, who was appointed to fill a vacancy left by former trustee Michael Dubois, has quickly distinguished herself as a thoughtful and effective member of the board. Her perspective is grounded in service, and her insights have strengthened board deliberations in a short period of time.
Together, Joe and Nancy bring the right mix of continuity, integrity, and forward-looking energy needed to guide the library through its next phase.
The South Shore Press urges residents of the Tri-Hamlet community to support the 2025 budget and return these two capable leaders to the board. For far less than the cost of a fast-food combo meal each month, you are ensuring access to one of the most innovative, inclusive, and essential community resources available.
Please take the time to vote on Tuesday, April 22. It’s a small action that can pay enormous dividends — for your family, and for your community.