The Unlucky Thirteen: Suffolk DA Tierney Dismantles Gang-Related Car Theft Ring


DA Tierney (podium) joined on Tuesday, March 4 by Police Commissioner Catalina on his right, and the prosecutor trying this case, ADA Kenneth Collado (his far left). | SSP

Representatives from both Long Island counties flocked to the Suffolk Police Academy gymnasium in Brentwood on Tuesday, March 4 to witness yet another victorious press conference.

Suffolk District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney and company netted thirteen fresh defendants the day prior. 

“Through meticulous investigation and collaboration with our law enforcement partners, we’ve dismantled a sophisticated criminal operation that targeted neighborhoods throughout our county,” said DA Tierney. 

The baker's dozen are charged with breaking into 52 vehicles, stealing 15, and swiping 75 credit cards—through which they raked up $40,000 in fraudulent purchases—since February of 2023.

Those arrested are all alleged associates of the Local Hempstead and Freeport Gang who call themselves both “5-L” and the “CC Boyz.” 

“What this gang didn’t count on,” notes Suffolk County Police Commissioner Kevin Catalania, “was the tenacity of our detectives to uncover their schemes. I commend the Fifth Squad, the District Attorney’s Office and our law enforcement partners that sent a clear message  that property crime is not victimless and one we are focused on.” 

In one security footage-documented instance, which Tierney showed members of the assembled media brass at Tuesday’s presser, ring-leader Shawn Mullen—who deployed his partners in crime to similarly act upon cars they knew to be unlocked with fobs present inside—even backed a blocked-in car parked within the driveway of a residence in suburban Commack directly onto grass before speeding off. 

This crew did not shy away from conspiring in broad daylight, either, as was equally demonstrated.

Mullen, 24, of Hempstead, personally broke into approximately 35 vehicles and outright stole 14 of them, charges allege. He faces a top count of Grand Larceny in the Second Degree, a class C Felony. He is charged with 197 counts total, including 178 of the felonious persuasion. He has been held on bail since August 2024.

Rounding out the roster of alleged car and identity thieves all due in court this month and next: Trevon Brandon-Douse, 26, of Freeport; Zion Fenner, 25, of Freeport; Jaquan Wilson, 21, of Hempstead; Edwin Pierre, 25, of Freeport; Damien Patrice, 27, of Hempstead; Jarell Lanier, 25, of Freeport; Jamal Woodside, 24, of Freeport; Kavon Wilson, 21, of Hempstead; Ramadan Cruz, 28, of the Bronx;  Andrew Lawrence, 23, of Hempstead; Joshua Lee Garrett, 20, of Bethpage; and Brianna Patterson, 32, of Hempstead. 

The case is being prosecuted by Assistant District Attorney Kenneth Collado, a Hauppauge (’10) graduate. 

Detective Matthew Messina of the Suffolk County Police Department’s Fifth Squad and Detective Investigator Jean Graf of the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Gang  Task Force led the investigation with assistance from Postal Inspector Robert Moerler of the US  Postal Inspection Service.  

“Here’s a message for every would-be criminal out there,” said USPIS New York Division Acting Inspector in Charge Brendan T. Donahue.  “If you try to exploit the postal system  for criminal use, Postal Inspectors will be on the case, and we’ve had a lot of practice arresting  fraudsters, over 250 years’ worth.”

“Let it be clear,” Tierney reiterates, “in Suffolk County, you cannot steal other people’s property with impunity.”


Organizations Included in this History


Daily Feed

Local

The King is Back in the South Shore Press

The legendary Long Island journalist Karl Grossman’s latest column.


Sports

Don't Expect Bregman to Pay Off

This week, one of the bigger names in the free agency cycle signed with the Chicago Cubs, and fantasy managers everywhere sighed. Usually, anyone heading to Wrigley Field is viewed as a positive, but for Alex Bregman, more information has emerged suggesting this move could spell trouble for his fantasy outlook. Bregman is a right-handed pull hitter who previously played in two of the more favorable home parks for that profile in Houston and Boston. Both parks feature short left-field dimensions that reward pulled fly balls and help inflate power numbers.


Sports

Futures Bettors Will Be Smiling

The College Football Championship is set, and it pits two of the more unlikely teams against each other. Indiana may have the largest living alumni base in the country, with more than 800,000 graduates, but few expected the Hoosiers to reach this stage. They feature zero five-star recruits and have instead relied on depth, discipline, and consistency while dominating all season long.