New York's New Gun Law Stirs Constitutional Debate Amid Concerns of Bureaucratic Inefficiency

A change in New York State's gun laws has ignited a firestorm of debate surrounding Second Amendment rights. Incorporated into the Concealed Carry Improvement Act and signed by Governor Kathy Hochul last year, the law moves the responsibility for firearm and ammunition background checks from the Federal Bureau of Investigation to the New York State Police.

While framed as a public safety enhancement, the law has sparked concerns about its constitutional standing, the effect on law-abiding gun owners, and potential administrative snags. A 2019 study by The Heritage Foundation underscored that concealed carry licensees are mainly law-abiding, contributing to just 0.7% of all gun-related homicides over 15 years.

The legislation introduces a $9 fee for each firearm background check and a $2.50 fee for every ammunition check. Governor Hochul contends that these fees will finance a "more integrated and efficient process" within the New York State Police's background check system. Critics, however, see this as an expansion of already burdensome bureaucracy, posing questions about the system's capacity to efficiently process an influx of background checks.

The lack of comprehensive guidelines for implementing the new law has confused gun owners and retailers. "The fees are minimal but necessary," insists Hochul, yet the ramifications for everyday gun users may be significant. A sports shooter, for instance, could face an extra $130 in yearly costs for ammunition checks alone. Such costs and potential processing delays could form the basis for a constitutional challenge.

The shift from federal to state oversight is fraught with concerns about the New York State Police's ability to manage the surge in background check requests efficiently. "If the online system crashes, we're essentially unable to make any sales. It's a serious issue," warns Jeff Bannister, owner of Just Holster It, a Suffolk County gun retailer.

Disqualifications for ammunition purchases include various public safety risks, such as felony convictions and substance abuse. Dealers are required to register online for a round-the-clock background check system. Appeals against background check denials must be filed within 30 days, with the state obligated to provide a reason for denial within the same period.

New York State aims to allay system reliability fears by launching an automated phone system for background checks this coming October. However, as crime rates, particularly in areas like New York City, show no sign of abating, the law's effectiveness in enhancing public safety is still debatable.

File Photo

Nevertheless, the specter of bureaucratic inefficiency looms most significant, given New York's less-than-stellar track record in practical administration. Critics wonder if adding another layer of state-level bureaucracy will improve public safety or contribute to the quagmire of inefficient government operations.

Both supporters and detractors are keenly watching the law's rollout, which could impact New York's gun owners and set a precedent for similar regulations nationwide.