The South Shore Press
← Back to Opinion
Opinion

Hartford Enjoined Connecticut's ICE Mask Law on the Same Supremacy Grounds Applied to New York

Judge Vernon Oliver issued a preliminary injunction against Senate Bill 397 as applied to federal officers. Gov. Kathy Hochul should take note.

By Howard Roark
Hartford Enjoined Connecticut's ICE Mask Law on the Same Supremacy Grounds Applied to New York
The Abraham A. Ribicoff Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse stands at 450 Main Street in Hartford, Connecticut, in a file photograph from August 29, 2010.Credit: Grondemar / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

On Nov. 20 a federal judge in Hartford froze the part of Connecticut's new immigration law that would have required federal agents to bare their faces and wear name tags. Judge Vernon Oliver, a Biden appointee and former Connecticut assistant attorney general, found that Sections 3 through 6 of Senate Bill 397 probably clash with the Constitution's Supremacy Clause, and he issued a preliminary injunction in the Justice Department's suit, No. 26-CV-758. New York wrote a similar law this spring, and a judge froze it in August. Gov. Kathy Hochul had not announced a replacement as of Nov. 22.

Section 6 of the Connecticut law made it a class D misdemeanor, with a jail term of up to 30 days, for any peace officer, federal agents among them, to wear a face covering while dealing with the public, and it required visible badges and name tags during planned arrests or public interactions. Sections 3 and 5 give Connecticut's inspector general authority to examine deadly-force cases involving federal agents and to bring charges, and Section 4 sets the state's standard for when force is justified. Oliver wrote that Section 6 "plainly imposes conditions on how federal officers must conduct and present themselves during the course of their federal duties," that the Justice Department is "almost certain to succeed" against it, and that it "places federal officers and their families at a heightened risk of retributive attacks."

Oliver removed Attorney General William Tong as a defendant and held that the inspector general cannot be enjoined on the mask section, since he has no power to enforce it. Tong's office said it is "reviewing the decision and evaluating next steps," and the court docket showed no appeal of the order as of the morning of Nov. 22. On Nov. 17, three days before the Hartford order, Judge Christina Snyder in Los Angeles signed a permanent order after California agreed to stop defending its mask and identification laws. The Ninth Circuit had already held on Oct. 14 that a state may not directly regulate federal officers without authorization from Congress, and federal judges in Philadelphia and Virginia ruled the same way on similar rules this summer.

New York's version is the MELT Act, sponsored by Assemblymember Tony Simone and Sen. Patricia Fahy and folded into the budget Hochul signed in late May. It prohibits officers at every level of government, federal agents among them, from wearing face coverings when they deal with the public. On Aug. 3, about two months after the signing, Judge Mae D'Agostino, sitting in upstate New York, enjoined it as applied to federal agents, writing that "settled law establishes that federal, not state, authorities make the policies that animate the enforcement of federal immigration laws." Homeland Security officials said they would not comply either way: "we will not abide by unconstitutional bans."

The budget Hochul signed also bans 287(g) agreements, creates a state cause of action against federal agents, restricts immigration officers' access to schools and hospitals, and spends about $74 million on lawyers for people facing immigration cases. Hochul and James, the attorney general, said New York taxpayers "should not have to foot the bill for any collaboration with ICE." On Nov. 20 a federal magistrate granted leave for Nassau's county executive, Bruce Blakeman, who called the state's ICE cooperation ban "very, very bad and dangerous," to join a sheriffs' lawsuit against it. The public docket, last updated at 4:33 p.m. on Nov. 20, still showed no signed amended complaint as of Nov. 22. The governor's priority is protecting people who are in the country illegally, and the cost falls on citizens, whose local officers are barred from helping.

DHS counted 647 assaults on ICE from Jan. 20, 2025, through Sept. 20, 2026, against 37 during the first 20 months of the Biden administration, and it says death threats are up 8,000 percent. A 2025 review of federal court filings found a smaller rise in assault charges. Prosecutors in Los Angeles said three women followed an ICE agent home in August 2025, livestreamed the chase and told bystanders an ICE agent lived there. A jury convicted two of them of stalking this year, though it acquitted all three on a charge of conspiring to disclose his personal information.

Suffolk's two House members, Rep. Nick LaLota and Rep. Andrew Garbarino, both voted yes on the DHS funding bills the House passed this year, H.R. 7147 on Jan. 22 and H.R. 7744 on March 5. The second carried $20 million for body cameras and no ban on face coverings. Two Democratic bills on agent identification, H.R. 4176 and H.R. 7233, and the Republican anti-doxxing bill, H.R. 5118, have not reached a floor vote, so neither congressman has a recorded vote on them. Garbarino, who chairs the Homeland Security Committee, said on Feb. 10 that threats against federal officers' families have risen significantly, and his remarks never mentioned masks. LaLota wrote on Sept. 2 that he supports body cameras and more training for immigration officers and opposes local limits on cooperation with ICE. Neither has stated a position on mask bans or on H.R. 5118 in any public record.

Oliver's order rests on the same Supremacy Clause reasoning Judge D'Agostino applied to New York's mask rule on Aug. 3. Courts have now blocked those mask or identification rules for federal agents in California, New York, Connecticut and Virginia, and a federal judge in Philadelphia blocked a city ordinance of the same kind. Hochul had not announced a replacement as of Nov. 22.

You Might Also Be Interested In